Book Review: The Bird King by G. Willow Wilson

Pros: interesting characters, great melding of history and myth

Cons:

Fatima is one of the sultan’s concubine’s in Alhambra, 1491AD. Amid the siege and her anger at her lack of freedom, her only comfort is Hassan, a gay scribe who can create maps to places that don’t exist. When a delegation from the Spanish monarchs arrives, Hassan’s life is put in danger and Fatima flees with him, hoping to escape the inquisitorial eye and find a better life.

I loved the blending of history and myth and the clash of beliefs that form the foundation of this novel.

The author has a solid grasp on the events and world of 1491, including a lot of minor details that bring the world to life.

I loved her depiction of jinn, which was different from any I’ve read before and made them fascinating. The island being a part of both Islamic and Christian myth was a nice touch, showing that some things are universal.

Beyond the jinn, there’s the magic associated with Hassan’s maps. It’s subtle and beautiful and while the plot hangs on it, it’s sparingly used.

The characters questioned their actions at every point in the book, which made them feel real. They blamed each other for bad decisions. They forgave each other for outbursts they regretted. Fatima is so full of anger and so unaware of the world outside the palace that her growth arc was huge. She’s very passionate and her reactions run the gamut. Luz was absolutely terrifying and I loved that the author played on a modern understanding of what the inquisition was to avoid graphic descriptions. There’s a little information but mostly the book relies on hints of what happens to those put to the question.

The book is fairly fast paced, with the characters constantly running into trouble.

If you like history with a hint of magic, this is a great read.

Out March 22nd.

Book Review: The Apprentice’s Masterpiece by Melanie Little

Pros: flawed characters, interesting style, lots of accurate historic details

Cons: limited plot

Fifteen year old Ramon Benveniste is a converso, a Christian with Jewish ancestors, living in Cordoba in 1485. As an apprentice in his father’s scribe business he knows things are tough as the Spanish inquisition puts more suspicion on those with their background, chasing away prospective clients in an already hostile environment. The family is given a Muslim slave, which makes them even more cautious about breaking rules of perception. The two boys don’t get along, and Ramon’s hasty decision one day changes both their lives.

While fiction, the book is solidly rooted in a factual portrayal of Spain at this time. The country shifted quickly from Muslim rule - where the three major religions were legally practiced, to Christian rule, where Jews were expelled, then converted, then persecuted, then expelled again, and Muslims were conquered, then converted/expelled/persecuted too.

The book is told in free form verse poetry. Each poem describes an event or scene and is from a few verses up to two pages long. It’s astonishing how much description and information is packed into so few words. Both the prologue and epilogue explain background information necessary for enjoying the story.

It’s subtitled a story of medieval Spain. There’s only a limited plot as the story focuses on the two boys and how they interact with each other and the world at large. The first and third sections are from Ramon’s point of view and cover short periods of time, while the second section is from Amir, the slave’s, point of view, and relates events that take place over several years.

The author pulls no punches about the brutality and reality of the history she’s relating. There’s a brief description of an auto da fe, a burning of heretics in the town square, told via a nightmare Ramon has after being forced to witness the execution. 

Both characters are flawed but approach the world from their own unique experiences. They both have histories and make decisions they later regret. They also learn from past mistakes, and grow as individuals.

It’s an interesting style and a quick read. If you’re not familiar with medieval Spanish history than you’re in for quite an education.